PDA

View Full Version : [Debate] Hannah Montana


Dr Shaneman
19-01-2009, 21:29
This is to settle the debate once and for all, is she good or just plain crap?
I was asked to do this Apollo Justice style like a court room so pressent your evidence/arguements why you think she good or bad.
You may shout "OBJECTION" when it's necesary.

Session started!

Rayne
19-01-2009, 21:34
OBJECTION!

This thread is instant fail! The members here have the combined musical taste of a dead panda, even with my utter awesomeness they probably won't see the light :P

Kaito-kun
19-01-2009, 21:40
OBJECTION!

This thread is instant fail! The members here have the combined musical taste of a dead panda, even with my utter awesomeness they probably won't see the light :P
EINSPRUCH!!!

How can you support something so cooperate-ly designed to make money from pre-teen American girls in the same vein as products like the High School Musical franchise? By supporting it you're just acting as an embarrassment to yourself and others.

And anyway, even a dead panda has tastes better than Hannah Montana.

DarkHedge
19-01-2009, 21:44
ARE YOU ALL RIGHT? (I fail at DU captions)

I will never, ever, ever support some preteen gal who has commercial success due of a SHIT voice who must be carrying ultrasonic waves to make the said preteens think it's cool.

"DIE IN A CRASH COMING OUT OF TURN THREE!"

Rayne
19-01-2009, 21:44
EINSPRUCH!!!

How can you support something so cooperate-ly designed to make money from pre-teen American girls in the same vein as products like the High School Musical franchise? By supporting it you're just acting as an embarrassment to yourself and others.

And anyway, even a dead panda has tastes better than Hannah Montana.

The reason it became popular in the first place was that the music was catchy, it was then that disney rolled out an entire franchise and product lines. Like High School Musical, I didn't like it but there was some talent and cheeryness behind it.

Don't bring embarrasment into anything, no one should have to be embarrased for what they like :D and don't make me bring up the kind of things you're into boy-o.

Have you listened to any of the albums? Ah, thought not.

SegaMark
19-01-2009, 22:43
I thought I'd also add, she isn't legal... Urgh.

Wolfdemon59
20-01-2009, 00:58
OBJECTION! What kinda thread is this xD You can already see the early stages of fame going to her head, shes going to end up like Britney Spears and Paris Hilton xD
Bad enough shes brain watching every little girl thanks to Disney >.>
If Walt disney is still alive he will be very pissed to see what his company has become,

Killer French Bread
20-01-2009, 12:18
She is nothing but a stain on the great reputation of living legend Billy Ray Cyrus.

Dr Shaneman
20-01-2009, 13:18
OBJECTION! What kinda thread is this xD You can already see the early stages of fame going to her head, shes going to end up like Britney Spears and Paris Hilton xD
Bad enough shes brain watching every little girl thanks to Disney >.>
If Walt disney is still alive he will be very pissed to see what his company has become,
Mainly, it's to settle the case once and for all and Rayne said he's take on the net if need be.

I'm liking that poll result.

Shadid
20-01-2009, 16:48
Epic OBJECTION!

I really, REALLY hate Montana, she's terrible and really irritating. And the PT dub's the same shite, bad acting equals worse dubbing. >_>
Besides, Miley's like Spears, but WORSE! O_O
And yes, the poll's results are going well, continue. XD

Rayne
20-01-2009, 17:17
Miley Cyrus is a talented vocalist :)

When you accept it for what it is, cheeszy ready-made teen pop, its very enjoyable and makes a great change to the tunes we usually get shoved on us.

I don't see how she's irritating at all really :/ perhaps you've seen too much advertising?

Personally I don't like spears, I would argue the comparison too. Spears was a stripper that got lucky, Cyrus is more like....a wannabe avril lavigne, if you've heard her new album :) its not too shabby

Rayne will take on the net if need be, and more importantly, Rayne will win >:3 I have many tricks up my sleeve, if I really want to win the poll, I only need to ask one forum..

mikevieira
20-01-2009, 18:07
OBJECTION!
...
Hum... I mean, I don't really know the story but when I was a kid and watched cartoons, a hero was a guy that was geek and then turned into a super-hero without no one knowing.
Now the class' pop chick transforms into a star and suddenly she's a star in the real world? That's as ridiculous as Tobey Maguire suddenly getting super powers.

Rayne
20-01-2009, 18:47
OBJECTION!
...
Hum... I mean, I don't really know the story but when I was a kid and watched cartoons, a hero was a guy that was geek and then turned into a super-hero without no one knowing.
Now the class' pop chick transforms into a star and suddenly she's a star in the real world? That's as ridiculous as Tobey Maguire suddenly getting super powers.

LOL, Best counter-argument, ever.

I actually thought it was two different people :D it was Katio that told me they weren't....funny that he would know so much....hmm....*ponders*

I know its a bit stupid really isn't it? :P but oh well

DarkHedge
20-01-2009, 18:51
If someone spots the guy who voted yes, please get them in front of my scope. And tell him he's an hero.

Well seriously, what are super heroes nowadays if we except recycling the good old stuff? They're nothing. C'mon, even regular cops are more fun to watch than Hannah Montana. And the Tony one is INFINITELY MORE VALUABLE.

Rayne
20-01-2009, 18:52
If someone spots the guy who voted yes, please get them in front of my scope.

*waves*

BluePuyo
20-01-2009, 18:54
I didnīt have the most minimal idea who was she, until I saw her in this thread (http://www.radiosega.net/forum/showthread.php?t=1488).
I donīt mind too much, I donīt know her after all, but if she is too popular may be for a reason.
Oh, and Disney channel is very bland, for me is like if it never existed. No wonder why I didnīt heard of she.

I would vote as "NO", but since I donīt know her, and I donīt care, and because it seems sheīs gonna to lose in this thread anyway, I leave it here. =P

Reknoc
20-01-2009, 19:11
Personally I don't like spears, I would argue the comparison too. Spears was a stripper that got lucky, Cyrus is more like....a wannabe avril lavigne, if you've heard her new album :) its not too shabby

So you're an Avril fan aswell? Are you sure you're not a 14 year old girl?

Rayne
20-01-2009, 19:14
So you're an Avril fan aswell? Are you sure you're not a 14 year old girl?

@Blue - Most people don't know her at all :P they're just voting no because 'iz diznae'

I loved Avril's first album, it had some real great acoustic tracks, her second was good, I picked it up super cheap and I haven't got her third (is she on three? or four?)

I remember the girlfriend song from it though o.o ugh...catchy but...well...bubblegum

SuperMatt723
20-01-2009, 19:26
Miley Cyrus is a talented vocalist :)

When you accept it for what it is, cheeszy ready-made teen pop, its very enjoyable and makes a great change to the tunes we usually get shoved on us.

I don't see how she's irritating at all really :/ perhaps you've seen too much advertising?

Personally I don't like spears, Spears was a stripper that got lucky


OBJECTION!

First of all, Britney Spears was a child star at first, made awesome albums then left the music scene. and plus, her music was actually good.


And now to the main point. I will give you the American male's point of view. First of all, guys DON'T like Hannah Montana. first of all , ill say, the show is actually quite funny. ive pitied myself for laughing, but it is. But hearing Miley's Crappy accent in every single episode irritates me to the extreme. one thing that frustrates me about it is miley's friend, Lily, or actress Emily Osment. She was casted ORIGINALLY as Hannah, but was taken off because billy ray came on in and was like, "im billy ray, and my daughter should be lead and not lily, blah blah blah" so that was switched. and theat moves me on into.....

THE MUSIC. for us americans, you cant put on TV without seeing Hannah montana or mileys face on the television. and they play the same songs over and over and over! its very irritating to hear mileys terrible accent during all of her songs.it sounds like 2 pigs squealing and a horse dying, well in my opinion at least. it really is that bad when you hear it everywhere.


The Product placement. is. the worst part. theres hannah montana tooth brushes, hannah montana wigs, shirts CD's, hannah montana this, and that. you see little kids walking around with hannah bookbags and luchboxes, and loads of CRAP! Disney, if your reading this, get rid of Hannah montana, and give us good shows and stuff. put Lizzie McGuire back on air.


and thats my Hannah rant. Tune in next time to hear my Jonas Brothers rant.

Dr Shaneman
20-01-2009, 21:43
@Blue - Most people don't know her at all :P they're just voting no because 'iz diznae'

I loved Avril's first album, it had some real great acoustic tracks, her second was good, I picked it up super cheap and I haven't got her third (is she on three? or four?)

I remember the girlfriend song from it though o.o ugh...catchy but...well...bubblegum
I have seen it so I CAN vote.

Rayne
20-01-2009, 22:01
I have seen it so I CAN vote.

I haven't seen it, its an argument about the music, not the show :P has anyone here actually listened to the albums?

Dr Shaneman
20-01-2009, 22:12
I haven't seen it, its an argument about the music, not the show :P has anyone here actually listened to the albums?
It's about her as a whole actually.

Rayne
20-01-2009, 22:28
It's about her as a whole actually.

It is? :\ I didn't think so

Kaito-kun
20-01-2009, 22:35
It is? : I didn't think so
I'm sorry my friend but it is about her as a whole.

We're only doing this intervention because we care.

Rayne
20-01-2009, 22:57
I'm sorry my friend but it is about her as a whole.

We're only doing this intervention because we care.

This cropped up after the album cover and the fact I mentioned I liked the music :P that's what its always been about, in my mind.

Even then >_> haven't watched the show, I don't get the disney channel. Hannah or miley's albums both are fun and the merchandise is only to be expected, its no less than the towels and mousemats spiderman or the transformers have.

Dr Shaneman
20-01-2009, 23:13
This cropped up after the album cover and the fact I mentioned I liked the music :P that's what its always been about, in my mind.

Even then >_> haven't watched the show, I don't get the disney channel. Hannah or miley's albums both are fun and the merchandise is only to be expected, its no less than the towels and mousemats spiderman or the transformers have.
But they're better.

MrEthernex
23-01-2009, 07:46
INTERJECTION!

lol, but I don't like Hannah Montana. This is how it goes: Billy Ray Cyrus (BRC) pays Disney money for show. BRC gets show. BRC casts daughter for main role. BRC rides daughter's fame to the top! ???? PROFIT!

What's even lulzier: Miley Cyrus and Hannah Montana Double Concerts. Star both Miley Cyrus and Hannah Montana. THE SAME PERSON. She takes five to go put on a blonde wig and makeup.

Oh, and she can't sing. Just like the Jonas Brothers. And Demee Levato (idk how to spell her name).

Disney = FAILED ROCKSTARS
</rant>

SuperMatt723
23-01-2009, 13:05
INTERJECTION!

lol, but I don't like Hannah Montana. This is how it goes: Billy Ray Cyrus (BRC) pays Disney money for show. BRC gets show. BRC casts daughter for main role. BRC rides daughter's fame to the top! ???? PROFIT!

What's even lulzier: Miley Cyrus and Hannah Montana Double Concerts. Star both Miley Cyrus and Hannah Montana. THE SAME PERSON. She takes five to go put on a blonde wig and makeup.

Oh, and she can't sing. Just like the Jonas Brothers. And Demee Levato (idk how to spell her name).

Disney = FAILED ROCKSTARS
</rant>


amen. exactly what i meant with my long ass response that no oner read.

Sonicdude1995
23-01-2009, 13:27
OBJECTION

Hannah Montana sucks! The Disney series nowadays are all crap! High School Musical was the most crappiest of all! As the years past, the Disney series seems to get worst!

Captain Monkfish
25-01-2009, 15:39
Who the hell is Hannah Montana?

Rayne
25-01-2009, 17:24
Who the hell is Hannah Montana?

Think Jesus + Microphone + Chocolate Sauce + Disney

Gecko.Guy
25-01-2009, 19:31
OBJECTION

Hannah Montana sucks! The Disney series nowadays are all crap! High School Musical was the most crappiest of all! As the years past, the Disney series seems to get worst!
I agree wat the hell was the whole reason of those movies and series, jsut a bunch of panzies prancing around....... Dont even get me started on Icarly..... Disney is just getting desperate. Hannah Montanna sucks on a whole different level, and do u see how her dad touches her, and goes to her bikinni photoshoots i think the dad has a thing for her miley cryrus(hannah montana).

Reknoc
25-01-2009, 19:42
Think Jesus + Microphone + Chocolate Sauce + Disney

So you don't like her? Because that's a terrible combination.

sonicbandicoot
25-01-2009, 22:12
Meh, she's just doing her job. I have no real hate on her, but her mudic could be better(seriously)... >3>

objection

Hannah Montana Sucks! The Disney Series Nowadays Are All Crap! High School Musical Was The Most Crappiest Of All! As The Years Past, The Disney Series Seems To Get Worst!

Amen! :>

Rayne
26-01-2009, 00:39
Well counting the poll, opinions and then factoring in that my opinion > all it looks like...

Hannah Montana wins :D nice work guys

MrEthernex
26-01-2009, 01:50
Who the hell is Hannah Montana?
Dude, you're lucky. I wish I didn't know her. CAN'T BE UNSEEN! :mad:

sonicfanRICH
15-03-2009, 07:53
Well I thought I'd post this here since this is the only thread about that girl.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/eonline/20090313/en_music_eo/104279

Owned.

miharbi_nami
18-01-2010, 19:37
Hannah Montana SUCKS PERIOD!!!!!! Yeah I know her songs are catchy and all that but seriously?! Who in their right minds would ever name their song the Ice Cream Twist???! And even have a dance for it? Come on people to vote NO! would be best.
And her voice is crappy anyways

Rayne
18-01-2010, 19:52
Whoa! Who else voted yes?

SegaMark
18-01-2010, 20:02
Hannah Montana SUCKS PERIOD!!!!!!

Some people would pay good money to watch that. ;)

Kaito-kun
18-01-2010, 20:04
Oh for the love of God! Why did this, of all the threads, have to be revived?!

Some people would pay good money to watch that. ;)
And that's just yucky.

Rayne
18-01-2010, 20:15
Some people would pay good money & jail time to watch that. ;)

Fixed :P

miharbi_nami
18-01-2010, 20:22
Some people would pay good money to watch that. ;)
True, but its mostly (and i hope) girls from ages 10-15 and they don't know any better (yet).

Mena
18-01-2010, 20:24
True, but its mostly (and i hope) girls from ages 10-15 and they don't know any better (yet).

I really hope you're not going on about the same thing Mark is... :unsure:

miharbi_nami
18-01-2010, 20:27
I really hope you're not going on about the same thing Mark is... :unsure:
What's that?

SegaMark
18-01-2010, 20:35
:lol:

Gavvie
18-01-2010, 20:46
Oh, the humour that can be found in the weirdest of places XD

Kool Chao
18-01-2010, 20:55
Seriously, this has to be one of the funniest series of posts ever on RS! XD

Silvertoad99
18-02-2010, 08:53
Do Not Want =P