Just noticed that this thread was never revived after the great purge of 2010 so I'm bringing it back.

The rules are simple: pick the choice you prefer from the post above and say why you'd choose it (Hopefully sparking a little bit of a discussion along the way) then post another two choices for the person below. If you're going to take part you must pick one of the two choices from the post above. (You can't do something along the lines of "Ohhhh, that's too hard to choose between!" and please, please try to keep it tasteful. Understand all that? (I'm sure you did, you're mostly intelligent people) Then let's go!

Would you rather loose an arm or a leg?